Connect with us

Florida State Seminoles

Overrated?

Florida Football Insiders

Published

on

Melina Myers-USA TODAY Sports

We are approaching the start of the college football season, and in a lot of ways, the games can’t get here soon enough. A perfect example of trying to fill the time and the internet space is anytime you trot out the “Overrated/Underrated” lists for anything.

In an item titled “Candid Coaches” CBSSports.com has done that with a survey of roughly 30 anonymous FBS coaches and they published it this weekend. And as you can imagine, we perked up when there were prominent Florida coaches names on both lists.

Let’s start first with a couple of ground rules, a survey like this that has over 90 of the 123 Division One bosses NOT giving input is far from scientific, and may not even be a true reflection of the group.

Two, CBS Sports didn’t give us any breakdown if most of the coaches were from one region or another. And further, and this is always a factor, if you are talking to coaches who have repeatedly lost to another coach/program on the field, in recruiting, etc. that should be taken into account, when they are being knocked.

Let’s call that the “Nick Saban Effect.” This is because, he’s repeatedly and consistently beaten almost everyone in the SEC and with the exception of Dabo Swinney, almost everyone else in the College Football Playoff too.

So the “Saban Effect” will make others resent your success, like the one coach (who has to be someone he whips regularly) that told the survey:

“If you had the No. 1 recruiting class in the country every year [you’d win like Nick Saban]. He shows up at every single game with a better roster than the teams he ‘s playing. … If you count cheating and getting the best players in the country as part of running a program, he’s the best in the country. It’s like saying an NFL coach is the best coach in the league if he gets 25 first-round picks every year.”

Yeah, that’s not Dabo Swinney saying that to CBS Sports.

So onto their “Overrated” list and when the name Willie Taggart is tied the top with James Franklin at 20% of the votes, it stood out to us at F.F.I.

Keeping in mind that it means only 5-6 coaches a piece, but still.

And while the one anonymous coach points out that FSU’s new boss has a losing career record, he leaves out a couple of important facts. Taggart turned Western Kentucky (his alma matter) from a losing season to a winning one and won a bowl game. He landed the USF job because of it.

And while the Bulls plummeted his first year to 2-10, he turned them back into a winner and won a bowl game before leaving for the Oregon job.

And, while Oregon has had monstrous success for two decades, when Taggart took over for Mark Helfrich, they were 4-8. He had a 7-5 record before getting the FSU job.

So, at three programs, he made them better quickly. And that’s the hope in Tallahassee.

Meanwhile, it’s obviously easy for coaches to knock FAU’s Lane Kiffin and he’s on that overrated list.

And there’s the one anonymous coach that said what others have said,  “If you’re born on third base, that’s great, but don’t think you hit a triple.” And, he’s referring to Kiffin getting the Raiders, Tennesee and USC jobs in succession with no winning track record.

Still Kiffin ran the table in Conference USA with the Owls and they won the title game and a bowl game in his first season. So, that has to be factored in.

And as for the “Underrated” list, we saw the name Dan Mullen of Florida, too.

Again, 8% means that roughly only 1 or 2 of the coaches polled thought so for him.

Still, Mullen did have some success with Mississippi State, which may be one of the 2-3 toughest places in the “Power Five” conferences to recruit and win.

And there’s no question that he knows quarterbacking and should be able to turn Florida back into an SEC yearly contender, quickly.

Lists are designed to create debate, criticism and even outrage.

Mostly, it’s something to get us to two weeks from now,…. when they games begin.

Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Advertisement Big Savings for Big Fans at Fanatics.com

Trending