A fascinating, detailed, “behind the scenes” look into Miami Dolphins scouting has been rolled out this week by Yahoo Sports. National college football writer Pete Thamel was given the opportunity and access to be on the road everywhere with the scouting staff of VP of football Mike Tannenbaum and GM Chris Grier. And, Thamel traversed the country for nearly a year with the staff watching what and how they do what they do.
The final part of the series was posted online late Wednesday night and gave great insight in particular to the scouts assisting on draft nights in the Miami war room late last week.
In particular, on Friday night in the second round, the Dolphins were contemplating taking Penn State TE Mike Gesicki, and Thamel picks it up from there:
When the Dolphins’ pick comes up in Round 2, Northeast scout J.P. McGowan gets called into the room by the brass. McGowan, 29, scouts the Northeast and does cross-checks on the tight ends. His trip to the room signaled Miami’s affinity for tight end Mike Gesicki. (It ended up being a busy night for McGowan, as Miami added tight end Durham Smythe in Round 4).
Thamel continued on the amount of time the scouting and front office staff had spent (for almost a year) on evaluating Gesicki.
Reports by McGowan, senior scout Terry Bradway and an in-person practice visit by executive vice president Mike Tannenbaum married with both a glaring need position and Gase’s vision. “He felt like he knew exactly how to use him,” Tannenbaum says. “That gave us great comfort. Not only to take him where we did, but that we’d put him in a position to be successful.”
As we chronicled last weekend, Gesicki is physical freak with great leaping ability for his size and strength. Obviously, that stood out the Fins (and probably several other teams) in the evaluation of why to take him, so highly.
Also, interesting from Thamel’s article Wednesday night was the Dolphins third round selection of Ohio State linebacker Jerome Baker, which went against one of their scouting philosophies. That philosophy was not drafting undersized linebackers, especially earlier in the draft. Baker is only 6’1 and 220lbs.
From Thamel, once more:
National scout Ron Brockington saw Jerome Baker, a third-round pick at linebacker, back in August at Ohio State. The vision became clearer through tape and the Big Ten title game, as the 6-foot-1 and 223-pound Baker didn’t fill the Dolphins’ oversized linebacker prototype. But he did fill a need….
And when general manager Chris Grier took a trip to Columbus later in the year, the picture crystalized that Baker may be the perfect exception to their preferred size paradigms. The Dolphins lacked a speedy linebacker versatile enough to cover tailbacks and tight ends last year – think Dion Lewis and Rob Gronkowski – and Baker could end up starting his career as a third-down specialist and flash his athleticism on special teams.
It should also be pointed out that Baker was a teammate of last year’s second round pick Raekwon McMillan with the Buckeyes and the Miami staffs knew a lot about Baker already because of that.
By the way, Ohio State has had an astounding 26 players selected in the last three (2016-18) drafts. So, if you are picking a place in the middle of the country to go scout and evaluate, that’s a good starting point.
Every team is thorough, some more than others, in the evaluation process, but it’s always interesting to see access/reporting like what Yahoo was given the opportunity to deliver.
Now, let’s see if the Fins draft picks deliver this fall.
CFB4 days ago
What does UConn leaving American for Big East mean for USF/UCF?
News1 week ago
After reported missing Rod “He Hate Me” Smart found safe
Jacksonville Jaguars1 week ago
No surprise Jaguars looking to recoup money from Telvin Smith
Jacksonville Jaguars1 week ago
Should Jaguars Telvin Smith “retire?”
Tampa Bay Buccaneers1 week ago
Cris Collinsworth/PFF- “Winston will challenge for passing yardage title”
NFL1 week ago
ESPN ranks off seasons of Bucs Dolphins and Jaguars
Miami Dolphins6 days ago
“Miami Miracle” up for ESPYS Play of the Year
Florida State Seminoles2 days ago
FSU unraveling last two years can’t all be blamed on Jimbo Fisher