Connect with us

Florida State Seminoles


Florida Football Insiders



Melina Myers-USA TODAY Sports

We are approaching the start of the college football season, and in a lot of ways, the games can’t get here soon enough. A perfect example of trying to fill the time and the internet space is anytime you trot out the “Overrated/Underrated” lists for anything.

In an item titled “Candid Coaches” has done that with a survey of roughly 30 anonymous FBS coaches and they published it this weekend. And as you can imagine, we perked up when there were prominent Florida coaches names on both lists.

Let’s start first with a couple of ground rules, a survey like this that has over 90 of the 123 Division One bosses NOT giving input is far from scientific, and may not even be a true reflection of the group.

Two, CBS Sports didn’t give us any breakdown if most of the coaches were from one region or another. And further, and this is always a factor, if you are talking to coaches who have repeatedly lost to another coach/program on the field, in recruiting, etc. that should be taken into account, when they are being knocked.

Let’s call that the “Nick Saban Effect.” This is because, he’s repeatedly and consistently beaten almost everyone in the SEC and with the exception of Dabo Swinney, almost everyone else in the College Football Playoff too.

So the “Saban Effect” will make others resent your success, like the one coach (who has to be someone he whips regularly) that told the survey:

“If you had the No. 1 recruiting class in the country every year [you’d win like Nick Saban]. He shows up at every single game with a better roster than the teams he ‘s playing. … If you count cheating and getting the best players in the country as part of running a program, he’s the best in the country. It’s like saying an NFL coach is the best coach in the league if he gets 25 first-round picks every year.”

Yeah, that’s not Dabo Swinney saying that to CBS Sports.

So onto their “Overrated” list and when the name Willie Taggart is tied the top with James Franklin at 20% of the votes, it stood out to us at F.F.I.

Keeping in mind that it means only 5-6 coaches a piece, but still.

And while the one anonymous coach points out that FSU’s new boss has a losing career record, he leaves out a couple of important facts. Taggart turned Western Kentucky (his alma matter) from a losing season to a winning one and won a bowl game. He landed the USF job because of it.

And while the Bulls plummeted his first year to 2-10, he turned them back into a winner and won a bowl game before leaving for the Oregon job.

And, while Oregon has had monstrous success for two decades, when Taggart took over for Mark Helfrich, they were 4-8. He had a 7-5 record before getting the FSU job.

So, at three programs, he made them better quickly. And that’s the hope in Tallahassee.

Meanwhile, it’s obviously easy for coaches to knock FAU’s Lane Kiffin and he’s on that overrated list.

And there’s the one anonymous coach that said what others have said,  “If you’re born on third base, that’s great, but don’t think you hit a triple.” And, he’s referring to Kiffin getting the Raiders, Tennesee and USC jobs in succession with no winning track record.

Still Kiffin ran the table in Conference USA with the Owls and they won the title game and a bowl game in his first season. So, that has to be factored in.

And as for the “Underrated” list, we saw the name Dan Mullen of Florida, too.

Again, 8% means that roughly only 1 or 2 of the coaches polled thought so for him.

Still, Mullen did have some success with Mississippi State, which may be one of the 2-3 toughest places in the “Power Five” conferences to recruit and win.

And there’s no question that he knows quarterbacking and should be able to turn Florida back into an SEC yearly contender, quickly.

Lists are designed to create debate, criticism and even outrage.

Mostly, it’s something to get us to two weeks from now,…. when they games begin.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Florida State Seminoles

No, Florida State is not getting rid of Willie Taggart

Florida Football Insiders



Rich Barnes-USA TODAY Sports

As our headline clearly presents, we interrupt the chaos and fantasy of those anti-Willie Taggart Florida State fans, who believe that somehow, he is not going to be their coach for the next couple of seasons.

Yes, it is bad right now for Florida State for several reasons. As our Matt Zemek laid out after Saturday’s blowout loss at Syracuse, you can only blame Jimbo Fisher for so much of it. And, because Taggart is in charge, he now will have to bear the brunt of whatever else goes on the next few games and to the end of 2018.

On Monday, Taggart met with the media and read from a prepared statement trying to reassure Florida State fans that the Noles will be better, and soon. Sure, there were many looking at that press conference and saying he doesn’t know what to do. However, FSU is only 1-2 with a winnable game coming this Saturday.

And, fundamentally, one of the things holding them back are talented skill players that must be addressed immediately; the play of the offensive line.  And as this article in the Tallahassee Democrat lays out, the Noles do not have a lot of options currently, in terms of new or better personnel.

Still, offensive line coach Greg Frey is very experienced at several other major programs and obviously, offensive coordinator Walt Bell has worked and called plays and had success in major college programs.

So, the belief that those two can improve the scheme and the blocking has to be there for the FSU faithful.

Now for the silliness that Taggart may only last one season.

That’s what it is, silliness.

He would be due over 21 million dollars in a contract buyout, if he was fired after this year, which Florida state would never pay at this stage.

Further complicating the situation, Florida State’s AD Stan Wilcox, who did the deal with Taggart last December to bring him from Oregon to Tallahassee, is leaving next month for a position with the NCAA.  So, the Seminoles new athletic director, yet to be hired, will have to probably be given a season to evaluate Taggart and that is going to be 2019.

And it’s important to remember the Taggart had a 2 – 10 record his first year at USF, but eventually turned them into a 10-win and bowl game winning program before leaving for the Pac-12 two years ago.

Now, Taggart did win a couple of games early in the Oregon season last year to take the pressure off, but still finished just 7-5, leaving before the Ducks bowl game.

So, perhaps the FSU offense will imporve this week against Northern Illinois, at least enough for Florida State to try and salvage a five or six wins season.

But, if it does not, Willie Taggart is still not going anywhere.

Continue Reading

Florida State Seminoles

FSU’s “Rag-tag” Taggart team tagged, flagged and bagged Saturday

Florida Football Insiders



Rich Barnes-USA TODAY Sports

Jimbo Fisher left behind a big mess. That’s what Week 1 taught the college football world about Florida State.

Week 2 against Samford, as bad as it was, nevertheless represented a game being played five days after the emotionally draining Virginia Tech opener. Young men — or old NFL veterans — are not supposed to play a violent sport twice in a span of roughly 120 hours. One can give FSU a full pass for that game. It contained very little real-world value in identifying what is right or wrong with this team.

But Week 3? On the road? With a full week of rest and relatively normal game-preparation circumstances? Against a Syracuse program which has struggled to play defense and struggled to win with any consistency over the past 15 years?

This was the time for Willie Taggart to show that, as much as Jimbo left him with a toxic cleanup site and insufficient hazmat gear, the Seminoles’ new coaching staff could manage a problematic situation and make necessary adjustments.

This was the week to show that damage control could define a season in which no one expected Florida State to be great. This project was all about the pursuit of competence and steadiness — not the dominance of old (that is a goal which always existed beyond this season’s capacities), but merely finding one’s footing as a program and setting the stage for 2019.

Instead, the Seminoles were “tagged” by Syracuse running for 231 yards, were “flagged” for 10 penalties, and the offense was “bagged,” by going a horrible 1-14 on third down, and being shutout deep into the fourth quarter.

Syracuse dominated Florida State 30-7. And, the blank stares from Taggart out onto the field shown on TV Saturday are only going to make Noles fans more venomous than they were before this one kicked off.

After this colossal failure in the Carrier Dome, Florida State has no footing.

It is sinking in quicksand… and its coach currently appears paralyzed in his attempt to do anything about it.

Continue Reading

Florida State Seminoles

FSU likely looking at high scoring-“track meet” at Syracuse

Florida Football Insiders



Rich Barnes-USA TODAY Sports

In what is the most prominent game of the weekend involving state school teams, FSU limps into the Carrier Dome for a Saturday noon game with Syracuse.

With growing concern about Coach Willie Taggart just two games in, the Noles need some positive things to happen and try to find a way to come out of Western New York with a victory.

One thing is obvious, Florida State’s defense is in disarray and with Syracuse having a powerful dual-threat quarterback, the Seminoles will likely have to win in a high-scoring “track meet” type game.

Even though Florida State played better in the second half defensively in both of their home games with Virginia Tech and Samford last week, there’s still real cause for concern.

For example, short week or not, Samford quarterback Devlin Hodges threw for 475 yards on the FSU defense and receiver Kelvin McKnight had a career night at Doak Campbell with 14 catches, 215 yards and 2 touchdowns.

Yes, Florida State slowed the Bulldogs down in the second half holding them only to one field goal. And did register four interceptions of Hodges. Still the most Ardent FSU supporters have to be concerned that Florida State has given up an average of 422 yards and 25 points in their first two games.

As for the ‘Cuse, QB Eric Dungey (above) is probably a better runner than passer, and the Orange have gone over 450 yards in both of their opening games while scoring 107 points.

Now, the quality of competition was Wagner and Western Michigan, but still yards are yards and points are points.

New FSU defensive coordinator Harlon Barnett has got to find some answers for the read option and Dungey’s Mobility. Unfortunately, Florida State doesn’t have the usual talented physical and fast front seven that fans have been accustomed to in Tallahassee over the years.

So more than likely, quarterback Deondre Francois, running back Cam Akers and receiver Nyquan Murray are going to have to help put a lot of points up on the board, if Florida State hopes to get out of the Dome with a much-needed ACC win

Continue Reading
Advertisement Big Savings for Big Fans at